AGP Picks
View all

JUSTICES SAY LEGISLATURE SHOULD DECIDE SETTLEMENT ENFORCEMENT

News originally published by

The Florida Bar

Supreme Court rotundaThe Florida Supreme Court on Thursday rejected a Civil Procedure Rules Committee proposal to add an enforcement mechanism to Rule 1.442 (Proposal for Settlement), saying that’s a decision for the Legislature.

In the October 2 opinion, In Re: Amendments to Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, Case No. SC2026-0170, justices wrote that the proposed amendments “appear to touch on matters of substantive law.”

The only purpose of Rule 1.442 “is to provide a procedural framework to implement the substantive requirements of section 768.79 regarding settlement proposals,” the opinion said.

Former Civil Procedure Rules Committee member Paul Regensdorf proposed the amendment at the suggestion of a “senior lawyer,” according to the committee report.

The senior lawyer recounted how a defendant accepted his client’s offer to settle, then failed to honor the terms, Regensdorf said.

“Eventually the defendant paid 1/3,” Regensdorf said. “The Judge has so far declined to enter a judgment, DESPITE the fact that the Proposal was also made under 768.79.”

The challenge is fairly common, the petition suggests.

“Other members indicated that they have personally had cases in which a judge would not enforce a proposal accepted under Rule 1.442 when the other side did not pay under the terms of the settlement — because the agreement did not contain a term specifying when payment was to be made, the courts felt they lacked the ability to create such a requirement.”

The committee proposed adding a new subdivision “j” (Enforcement of Accepted Proposal).

“After timely acceptance of a proposal, in the event of any breach or failure to perform under the agreement, the court on motion may impose sanctions, including costs, attorneys’ fees, or other appropriate remedies including entry of judgment on the agreement.”

The proposed language parallels the enforcement provision found in Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.730(d) (Completion of Mediation), the petition notes.

Rule 1.442 is titled “Proposal for Settlement,” and section 768.79 is titled “Offers of Judgment,” and the difference is causing confusion, Regensdorf wrote.

“The word ‘judgment’ does not even appear in the rule in the context of a proposal ripening into a ‘judgment.”

The lack of an enforcement mechanism is made worse “by the fact that an offer cannot contain ANY non-monetary terms whatsoever [except dismissals],” Regensdorf added.

Orlando personal injury attorney Tina Willis, who submitted the only comment, wrote that an enforcement mechanism would encourage more parties to settle.

“The current rule addresses the mechanics of making and accepting proposals in considerable detail, but it is silent on what happens when an accepted proposal is breached,” she wrote. “This gap has real consequences for the utility of the rule for injured plaintiffs.”

The statute gives a court “full jurisdiction” to enforce a settlement, but offers no “procedural roadmap,” Willis wrote.

“The statute does not specify what motion to file, what standard applies, what remedies are available, or what consequences attach to the breach.”

Under the existing rule and statute, parties are penalized for refusing a settlement proposal if they receive a worse result at trial, but there are no penalties for accepting an offer and failing to honor it, Willis said. That undermines “the rule's stated purpose of encouraging settlement and reducing litigation,” she contends.

Willis urged justices to strengthen the proposal by making enforcement mandatory and the penalties more substantial. Anything less, she said, would fail to improve compliance.

“I would suggest the Court consider substantial mandatory penalties such as multiplied damages — double or treble the amount of the accepted proposal.”

But committee members were “not in favor of taking away the discretion from the court in this matter,” they noted in their response.

A “substantial” sanction, the response states, “is outside of the committee’s purview,” as it would require legislative action to amend F.S. §768.79.

Legal Disclaimer:

EIN Presswire provides this news content "as is" without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article, kindly contact the author above.

Share this page:

Advanced Search Options

Search for:

Search scope:

Type:

Search in:

Date range:

The last

Sort by:

Sign up for:

Florida Observer

The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.